Wednesday, March 21, 2018

The OTHER Other Side

     Let's talk about transgendered people and the arguments surrounding that whole topic. Now, I need to make this clear that I'm not going to say things that are completely and universally right with no room for any other potions, I am speaking from my point of view and the logic presented to me; I hold the right to change my perspective when shown truths, lies or something more.

     The biggest religious debate I hear is Deuteronomy 22:5

Deuteronomy 22:5 says,
"The woman shall not wear that which pertaineth unto a man, neither shall a man put on a woman's garment: for all that do so are abomination unto the Lord thy God." (KJV)
Taken at just that, it sounds very much like the bible is taking a black and white stance against women wearing men's clothes, which in principle opposes transgenderism in at least appearance. IF you take it at just that one line, that is. The thing about interpreting biblical philosophies is that cross referencing and reading full portions is more important than taking sound bytes or tiny portions that seem to say concrete facts. 

For every truth in the bible, there are multiple sections that explain or expound on whatever it is that's being talked about. And in this exact reference, people 
think this is God's way of saying women should not wear men's clothes and vice versa. But in fact, reading thew whole chapter, it does not mention men wearing women's clothes or women wearing men's clothes anywhere else. What it does reference is respect and responsibility by talking about a person finding his brother's animal and not keeping it and helping their brother's animal (ox) if it falls down instead of not helping. 

The main principle being taught, if you read the chapter in full and see many concordances, explains the principle of not getting away from your own responsibility. A man should not act like a woman to get away from the rsponsibilities that are his and samer thing for a woman. 

This is not about transdgendered people and even if it did mean men shouldn't wear women's clothes, trans people aren't simply cross dressing so the issue is not even covered without context. And there's nothing else that tackles cross dressing for it's own sake or people who have to deal with feeling or desiring to be the other gender (I'm not talking about sexual preference here at all)

     Another issue the physical vs the emotional.

By that I mean trans people are emotionally not accepting what they physically are. And while physically our bodies are what they are and chromosomes are what they are, that's not all there is to it.

Studies have shown that trans people often (nothing is unanimous, almost ever) have closer brain functions to the sex they feel and act like more than the sex they were born.

It is also recognized in the DSM as gender identity disorder and while some may take offense to that, it does acknowledge that it's more than just an issue of people not accepting what they are. There are many articles and studies that prove that there is more than just people who are emotionally making a snap decision.

And then there is the other side of the emotional argument, the side I come from most often. When I tell people about me (the real me, that is), the first thing I explain is that I've been suicidal all my life and for the first time..I'm not. I'm not saying I don't suffer from suicidal thoughts ever but a really big weight has been lifted off my chest and I've been actually happy while learning how to freely live my life.

And that may be over emotional or not completely logical and it may go against my chromosomes but to not want to die is one of the biggest things I've ever experienced. I use this as a strategy when talking to someone who disagrees with transitioning because emotions are a very big part of what I'm going through.

     We're all trying to be happy during our short time on earth, other stuff happens and others take some of that happiness but overall we want to be happy. I want that too.

2 comments:

  1. Appearances are everything in societal acceptance. The Gender Binary is the law of the land. I had the GRS at age 60. Being complete and fitting in to the female sex was necessary for happiness. Gender is behavior. After GRS and completion of binary female transition. Gender behavior of woman is expected.

    ReplyDelete